The consultation, which ran from 9 January until 20 February, attracted 68 written submissions. The Committee also had meetings with 16 Tynwald Members and representatives of five local authorities.
Chairman Sally Bolton commented:
‘On behalf of the Boundary Review Committee I would like to thank all the members of the public who took the trouble to respond to the consultation, as well as the Tynwald Members and local authority representatives who came to meet us. It was a very useful exercise, providing valuable local insight which will be taken account as we prepare our final report to Tynwald.’
At present the Island has two three-seat constituencies (Rushen and Onchan), five two-seaters (the four Douglas constituencies and Ramsey), and eight one-seaters (Ayre, Castletown, Garff, Glenfaba, Michael, Peel, Malew and Santon, and Middle). This means that some individuals have three votes each in general elections, some have two and some have only one – depending on where they live.
There is also a considerable variation in the numbers of voters per MHK, from 49% above the average in Middle to 26% below the average in Glenfaba (based on 2010/11 figures). Tynwald has agreed that there should be equality of representation, that the 24 Keys seats should be divided into twelve constituencies with two Members each, and that the population size of constituencies should not vary from the average by more than 15%.
NOTES
The twelve two-seat constituencies proposed in the draft plan published by the Boundary Review Committee for consultation are listed below with general and approximate descriptions. The names are working titles only.
- North – the current constituencies of Michael and Ayre plus the parish of Maughold, from Garff
- Ramsey – the current constituency
- East – Laxey and Lonan, from Garff, plus Onchan parish and most of Birch Hill, from Onchan
- Onchan Urban – the current Onchan constituency minus Onchan parish and most of Birch Hill
- Douglas Western – based on the polling districts Anagh Coar, Ballaugton, Pulrose
- Douglas Central – Albany, Ballabrooie, Eastfield, Quay, St George’s, Somerset and Tynwald, plus part of Garden City
- Douglas Northern – Glencrutchery, Willaston and part of Garden City, plus a small part of Onchan parish
- Douglas Eastern – Crescent, Derby, St Ninian’s, Strand, Windsor
- Central – Middle plus the parish of Santon, from Malew and Santon
- South – Castletown plus Malew, from Malew and Santon, and Arbory, from Rushen
- South West – the current Rushen constituency minus Arbory
- West – Peel plus Glenfaba and a small part of North Malew
Appointed in December 2010 in compliance with a Tynwald resolution of July that year, the Boundary Review Committee has had two interim reports accepted by Tynwald following public consultation. In response to the first, in December 2011, Tynwald voted in favour of the principle of equality of representation so that all constituencies should return an equal number of MHKs.
It also agreed that constituencies should vary by no more than 15% in terms of their population numbers. The Committee produced its second interim report to Tynwald in October 2012. This resulted in Tynwald agreeing that the 24 House of Keys seats should be divided into twelve constituencies of two Members each. The Committee was directed to draw up constituency boundaries on this basis, and to report back to Tynwald by June 2013. The Boundary Review Committee is chaired by advocate Sally Bolton and the other members are Terry Groves, Ashton Lewis and Bob Riding.
