Employment Tribunal decisions
All decisions issued by the Employment Tribunal, since 1 Nov 2006, are listed below. Decisions issued before the Tribunals’ Centralised Administration was formed on the 1 Nov 2006 are not available on the website but can be viewed in the Register which is available for any person to inspect, during normal Office hours, at the Offices of the Manx Industrial Relations Service, 5th Floor, Victory House, Prospect Hill, Douglas, Isle of Man, IM1 1EQ.
The decisions are listed in date order, thereby meaning the oldest decision appears at the top of the list and any new decision added to this page is automatically displayed at the bottom of the list. We aim to publish decisions of the Employment Tribunal on this website within 3 working days of the decision being issued.
The decisions all have a standard naming convention applied. First, the case number is indicated and then details of the names of the parties involved are shown. The only difference you will see to the naming convention relates to the case number. Prior to 2008, the case number assigned to an application made to the Employment Tribunal was simply the next sequential number (1008, 1009, 1010, and so on), irrespective of the year in which the application was received. From January 2008, applications received were assigned a case number made up of the last two digits of the year in which the application was received and then the sequential number starting from 1 (for example, in 2008 the first application was numbered 08/1, the second 08/2, and so on). Case numbers changed in 2008 purely to assist the administration as it enabled staff to quickly identify how many applications had been received in any particular year, for any period, etc.
Details of upcoming Employment Tribunal hearings can be viewed by selecting the ‘Hearings Information’ tab.
How to search the information below
In order to read a decision, simply click on the names of the parties and the document should open. Having opened and viewed a particular decision, you should use the ‘Back’ function to navigate back to the list of all decisions. Please note that if you use the X (close) function when the document is open you will close the entire webpage. If you experience any problems in trying to view any of the decisions, please contact the Tribunals Office on 01624 685941.
If you are looking for a particular decision, you can search this page by holding down the ’Ctrl’ and ‘F’ keys on your keyboard to provide you with search functionality - you can then enter either the case number or the name(s) of either/both the parties (tip – the less search criteria you enter is the more matching results you will get returned). Please note that a search on this page can only search the wording contained in the naming convention applied to and displayed against the decision – it cannot look at the contents of the individual decisions.
However, once you select and view a decision you can then carry out a search within the document by again holding down the ’Ctrl’ and ‘F’ keys on your keyboard and, once the search field appears, by entering the relevant text that you wish to look for within the document – this may assist you if you simply want to see if a decision has any relevance to the situation you find yourself in, for example you may wish to quickly search the decision to see if it contains the words ‘unfair dismissal’. Although we hope that you find this useful, please note that any person searching the decisions for relevant cases should satisfy themselves as to the content and relevance of any decision published.
| Ref. No. | Parties |
|---|
| 913 | Yvonne Moore v Morris Brokers Limited |
| 852 | Marc Peter Deakin v St Christopher's Fellowship |
| 919 | Sio Heng (Sally) Chan v Norman Mackey and Mary Mackey t/a Ascot Hotel |
| 944 | Kent Safstrom v Port Erin Dental Surgery Limited, Fosterite Limited, Ian Phillips, Frank Balbo
|
| 845 | John Shallcross v Cignet Construction & Project Management Limited |
| 982 | Carla Alexandra Alves De Oliveira v La Mona Lisa Limited |
| 810 & 873 | Joyce Mummery v betinternet.com plc |
| 879 | Robert James Smith v Ultimate Interiors Limited |
| 846 & 859 | Mou-Qi Haung v Pisces Limited (t/a The Water Margin Restaurant)
|
| 964 | Mrs Angela Brenda Moffatt v Civil Service Commission
|
| 896 | Brenda Williams v Isle of Man Post |
| 988 | Leo Cussons v Ambitions Limited |
| 900 & 901 | Mr Carl Christopher Goodwin & Dr Joy Duffen v Global Coresports Limited |
| 806
| Dr Mohamed Ali Salih v Dept. of Health & Social Security & Dr Marie O'Sullivan & IPP Ltd |
| 976
| Bridget Carter v Scott Shipping Management Ltd |
| 988 | Leo Cussons v Ambitions Limited |
| 1024 | Geoffrey Griffiths v Ultimate Interiors Limited |
| 965
| Frank James Bowker v Barclays Private Client International Ltd |
| 974 & 999 | James Morgan Sharples v Ben Batoul, La Casa |
| 996 | Mark Jonathan Lewin v Close Bank (Isle of Man) Limited
|
| 1051 | Ian Rodney Pressley v Ultimate Interiors Limited (In Liquidation)
|
| 1058 | Steven James Clennell v Ultimate Interiors Limited (In Liquidation)
|
| 1042 & 1048 | Paul Stephens v JAK Limited |
| 1087 | Peter Quayle v Ultimate Interiors Limited (In Liquidation)
|
| 1056
| Duane Albert Quinney v Foxdale Precast Limited
|
| 1053 | Joseph Anthony Rooney v Netcetera Limited
|
| 1088
| Jamie Robert Kemp v C J Bridson Limited |
| 1061
| John Lee Christian v Barony Estate Limited |
| 1053 | Joseph Anthony Rooney v Netcetera Limited
|
| 1067
| William Lyell Hatch v Ocean Ford |
| 1004
& 1005 | Anthony Corlett and Philip Maule v Templeton Insurance Limited |
| 1118 | Seamus Martin Boorman v Ultimate Interiors Limited
|
| 1052
| Howard Coles v MFS 3 Limited t/a Manx Family Services |
| 1012 | Tracey McIver v Mark Jones t/a Sunset Dry Cleaners |
| 1094
| Thomas Donnelly v Graylaw Freight Manx Ltd |
| 1095
| Alison Moore v Seana Balakrishna (The Cosmetic Medical Centre)
|
| 1114 & 1116 | Rosemary Ann Hughes, David Henry Corlett v Nasaleze Limited |
| 839 | Archibald Andrew Gary Graham v St Christopher's Fellowship
|
| 1071
| Emma Louise Callow v Isle of Man Department of Health and Social Security
|
| 1078 | Lee John Jordan v Japan Direct Limited, Ron/Ray Corlett
|
| 1040
| Leonardo Savino v Nickel Limited t/a The Max Restaurant
|
| 998
| Brian Walker v Kingswood Honda Limited
|
| 1106 | Robert Edwin Cannell v Cedar Developments Limited
|
| 08/22
| Ian Martin Gerrard v A M Limited |
| 08/27
| Graeme Ross Merrick v Gordon Drinkwater t/a Making IT easy |
| 956
| Donna Marie Winterburn v Protours Isle of Man Limited |
| 1137
| Margaret Mary O'Reilly v Civil Service Commission |
| 08/16
| Richard Jonathan Nicol v Industrial Equipment Limited (In Receivership) |
| 1004
& 1005 | Anthony Corlett and Philip Maule v Templeton Insurance Limited |
| 08/89 | Victoria Greenwood v Cherry Orchard Aparthotel
|
| 08/26
| Kevin Rodney James Callister v Charlie Omar |
| 924 | Frank Noel O'Hare v St Christopher's Fellowship and St Christopher's Fellowship (Isle of Man)
|
| 08/02
| Patricia Whittle v Isle of Man Adoption Service |
| 08/76
| Leonard Trevor Cowin v Civil Service Commission |
| 1099
| Loretta Doreen Simpson v Neville Pearson and Lynn Pearson
|
| 08/83
| Wendy Joanne Hewer v Peter Faragher |
| 1084
| Clinton Lloyd Karte Bixter v BP Maritime Services (IOM) Ltd, Dorchester Maritime Limited etc. |
| 08/110
| Fiona Avril Karran v Energy Radio Limited
|
| 08/101
| Margaret Edna Griffiths v International Company Services Limited (now Daxter Holdings Limited) |
| 08/87
| John Edward Owen Millington v Chris Waterson t/a Christopher Barry Plastering Contractors
|
| 1138
| Kevin John Cowburn-Wood v Department of Health & Social Security |
| 08/106
| Cidalia Maria Soterio v John Hamilton t/a VJ's Perfect Cleaning Isle of Man |
| 08/02
| Patricia Whittle v Isle of Man Adoption Service |
| 08/86
| Mary Josephine O'Reilly v Donald Martyn Lowey trading as Lowey & Co |
| 08/24
| Paul James Fox v Barclays Private Clients International Ltd |
| 08/127
| Christine Higgins v Dave Mather, ETC Kitchens & Bathrooms |
| 08/116
| John Paul Martin v Bridson and Horrox Limited |
| 08/117
| George Osborn v Kennaa Properties Limited
|
| 08/128
| Robert James Love v ETC Kitchens & Bathrooms ETC Limited (David George Mather)
|
| 08/06
| Brian Murphy v Department of Health and Social Security
|
| 09/15
| Peter Ronald George Blount v C.S.I. Limited
|
| 1138
| Kevin John Cowburn-Wood v Department of Health & Social Security |
| 1117
| Rebecca Jayne Attwell v Braddan Parish Commissioners |
| 1004
& 1005 | Anthony Corlett and Philip Maule v Templeton Insurance Limited |
| 08/135
| Eric Saulnier v T J Playa Limited
|
| 08/121
| John Needham v Panelcraft Insurance Repair Centre Limited |
| 08/126
| Craig Roland Hewitt v Homerun Pizza Limited |
| 09/02
| Angela East v Braddan Parish Commissioners
|
| 09/50
| Atef Mohammad Salman v Nadeem Younus and Aisha Younus |
| 09/22
| Anthony David Murphy v Templeton Insurance Limited, Knox D'Arcy Operations Ltd, Richard Steele |
| 08/134
| Michael Mills v Island Mechanical Contractors Limited |
| 08/118
| Roderick Nielsen v Zurich Employment Services Limited
|
| 09/07
| Mr Barry Thomas Charles Coombes v Stewart Clague Services Ltd
|
| 1004
& 1005 | Anthony Corlett and Philip Maule v Templeton Insurance Limited |
| 09/57 | Elizabeth Jane Margaret Watson v Viewpoint Support Services Limited |
| 08/80
| Christina Rawlinson v Equiom Trust Company Limited |
| 09/43 | Gary Michael Dalton-Baker v Formula Fast Fit Limited |
| 08/136
| Philip Andrew Lennox v Island Mechanical Contractors Limited |
| 09/22
| Anthony David Murphy v Templeton Insurance Limited, Knox D'Arcy Operations Ltd, Richard Steele |
| 09/12
| Julia Vivienne Redhead v Worldwide Corporate Solutions Limited
|
| 09/19
| Mr Michael John Bradley v David Crowe Plant Hire Limited
|
| 09/62
| David James Connolly v T & P Kermeen (Family Butchers) Limited |
| 09/26
| Gary Ramsden v Bedouin Management Limited |
| 09/95
| Miss Lynn Russell v Jim Kearns (Ice Mann Food Service Limited) |
| 09/11
| Anthony Edward Raynor v Mitre Hotel (Ramsey) Limited
|
| 09/38
| Zarina Banu Khan v House & Home (Interiors) Limited
|
| 09/99
| Claire Collins v Parkview Holdings Limited t/a Open All Hours |
| 09/61
| David Damien Bowman v Heritage Homes Limited |
| 09/46
| John James Barry v Manx Gas Limited |
| 08/125
| Robert Leslie Orr v Age Concern Isle of Man |
| 10/08 | Christel Suzanne Borr v Angels Care Limited |
| 09/83
| Audrey Dianne Corrie v The Chocolate Box Limited |
| 09/106
| Bacar Cassama v Banana Computers Limited
|
| 10/10
| Alexander James Lea v Purple Online Accountancy Limited
|
| 09/93
| Annabell Louise Storm v Manx Telecom Limited |
| 09/100
| David John Connell v HSBC Bank Plc |
| 09/72
| Miss Lana Marie Cowley v Castlebay Seafoods Limited |
| 09/38 | Zarina Banu Khan v House & Home (Interiors) Limited |
| 10/35 | Emmanuel Augustus Amoah v Royal London Management Services Limited
|
| 09/04
| Glenn Kinley v J Kaneen Limited |
| 10/06
| Karen Wendy Sansom v Anthony C Waitland |
| 10/20
| Mr Andrew David Watterson v Chapters Limited
|
| 08/29
| Kathryn Butler v Civil Service Commission |
| 10/01
| Bujari Batite MacLaiman Aali v Gusto Restaurants Limited |
| 10/02
| Ahmed Salem Laagayed v Gusto Restaurants Limited
|
| 09/43
| Gary Michael Dalton-Baker v Formula Fast Fit Limited |
| 10/25
| Ian Anthony James v Trade Distribution Limited
|
| 09/59
| David Anthony Pownall v Isle of Man Airport |
| 09/41
| Mr Christopher Bernard Dunne v Manx Gas Limited |
| 10/39
| William Quentin Bailey v Active Maintenance Services Limited
|
| 10/07
| Juan Brain v Department of Transport |
| 10/63
| Michael John Phillips v Dusk Limited t/a The Hop Garden
|
| 10/65
| William Alexander Hastie v Pro-Tec Security Limited and Mr Barry Cox
|
| 09/78
| Terence Anthony Crook v N K Joinery Limited
|
| 10/91 | Derek Allan Stokes v Borough of Douglas |
| 09/27
| Edward Terence Miles v Woodgate Aviation Limited
|
| 10/97
| Andrew Brian Clothier v Stewart Clague Services Limited
|
| 10/83
| Mr Mark Ernest Anderson v Mr Steven George Perry t/a Splinters DIY Store |
| 10/42
| Egerton Thomas Morgan v Mount Murray Country Club Limited |
| 10/97
| Andrew Brian Clothier v Stewart Clague Services Limited
|
| 10/94
| Ean James Cannell v Peel Motor Body Ltd |
| 10/04 & 05 | Jason Lee Sarson & Margaret Alexandra (aka Sandra) Birtles v Civil Service Commission |
| 10/94
| Ean James Cannell v Peel Motor Body Ltd
|
| 10/44
| Ms Rita Cowan v Civil Service Commission
|
| 10/52
| Shannon Alexander Finlay v Foxdale Precast Limited
|
| 10/53
| John Robert McMullan v Foxdale Precast Limited |
| 10/91
| Derek Allan Stokes v Douglas Borough Council |
| 10/75
| Sarah Jane Spurdens v PTVB Management Limited
|
| 11/07
| Larissa Jodie McColgan v Bravo Foods Limited
|
| 10/103
| Sarah Elizabeth Puzzar v Mostly Manx Hampers Ltd
|
| 10/82
| Marcelo de Freitas Mazzitelli v Department of Community Culture and Leisure |
| 09/53
| Philip Older v Manhattan Aviation Services Limited
|
| 11/07
| Larissa Jodie McColgan v Bravo Foods Limited
|
| 10/73
| Anita Hogarth v The Sayle Gallery Limited
|
| 10/04 & 10/05 | Jason Lee Sarson & Margaret Alexandra (aka Sandra) Birtles v Civil Service Commission
|
| 10/27
| Aaron Michael Bernard Joughin v Gradan Limited |
| 10/107
| Adrian Colin Mayles v Home Run Pizza Limited
|
| 11/44
| Neil Jason Holden v Thermoguard IoM Limited
|
| 11/35,36 & 38 | Paul John Richardson, Nigel David Johnson and Pauline Noble v G4S Secure Solutions (Isle of Man) Limited |
| 10/27 | Aaron Michael Bernard Joughin v Gradan Limited |
| 10/90
| Mr Andrew Donaldson v Heron & Brearley Retail Brewery |
| 11/43
| Nigel Christopher Moody v Cubbin and Bregazzi Limited
|
| 10/108
| Mandy Maureen Wise v Barclays Private Clients International Limited
|
| 11/18
| Keith Campbell v Wheely Clean Limited |
| 10/58
| Hans Brink Albers v Barclays Private Bank and Trust (Isle of Man) Ltd |
| 11/50 | Sian Catherine Dimelow (nee Lewis) v Gian Paulo Atzori t/a Mop Hair |
| 11/21 | Michael Thomas Roberts v ARMS Ltd |
| 11/09 | Denize Lace v Denticare (Isle of Man) Limited (t/a Denticare Dental Spa) & Denticare Limited |
| 11/68 | Michael Robert Asbridge v Pride Window Cleaners Limited |
| 10/09 | Anthony Adenaike v Paddy Power Online Limited |
| 11/59 | Kevin John Callow v Swales Electrical Limited trading as Hoistline |
| 12/11 | Dr Dirk Heinz Hoehmann v The Department of Health |
| 11/51 | Colin Cauldwell v Fairways Trading Limited t/a The Garage Door and Gate Automation Company |
| 11/92 | Antoinette Venter v Chapters Limited |
| 11/109 | Sylwia Maria Figueiredo v Jennifer Jade Mullineux and John Charles Hamilton t/a Jennifer's Cleaning Services |
| 11/25 | Charles Stanley Lewin v Dandara Holdings Limited and Allied Services Limited |
| 11/108 | Joseph Dwight Quesada v Richard James Dangerfield and Jacqueline Maureen Dangerfield t/a Easy Clean |
| 11/57 | Sean Courtney v Ace Roofing Limited |
| 11/88 | Kirsten Marie Harrison v Resource Support Services (Isle of Man) Limited and George Skuszka |
| 11/55 | Mr Marcelo de Freitas Mazzitelli v Mr Robert Croan t/a Roberto's |
| 11/100 | Emilia Beresinska v MIBA Limited |
| 12/08 | Brian John Purdy v Pooil Vaaish Limited |
| 11/64 &11/65 | Brett McLinden and George Thomas Cottrell v Manx National Heritage |
| 11/62 | Mr Noel Patrick Redmond v DLP Limited |
| 11/77 | Richard James Signorio v Islander Chippy Limited |
| 12/07 | Ruth Louise Dermott v Fortress Management Services Limited |
| 11/64 & 11/65 Review | Brett McLinden and George Thomas Cottrell v Manx National Heritage |
| 12/08 Review | Brian John Purdy v Pooil Vaaish Limited |
| 12/25 | Angela Karen Davies v Ice Mann Food Service Limited |
| 12/13 | Malgorzata Magdalena Kopania v John Hamilton t/a Jennifer's Cleaning Services |
| 11/110 | Mark Colin Fort v G4S Secure Solutions (Isle of Man) Limited |
| 11/97 | Steven Robert Harding v Sefton Group plc |
| 12/07 Review | Ruth Louise Dermott v Fortress Management Services Limited |
| 12/12 | Edward Charles Rhodes v G E White Limited |
| 12/83 | James Peter Cleasby v Ace Hire & Sales Limited |
| 12/26 | Simon Hartley v Pooil Vaaish Limited |
| 12/19 | Helena Francis Kneale v Treasureland Limited |
| 12/62 | Adam Terrence O'Shaughnessy v G B M Tyres Limited |
| 12/19 Review | Helena Francis Kneale v Treasureland Limited |
| 12/02 | Edward Terence Miles v The Jet Centre Limited t/a The Private Jet Company |
| 12/06 | Fiona Elizabeth Mackie v Isle of Man Civil Service Commission |
| 12/64 | Robert Wilson Ayre v Derwent Holdings Limited |
| 12/85 | Paul Edward Price v (1) JCK Limited (2) JCK Environmental Limited |
| 12/96 | Melisa Leanne Susan Ardis v Parkview Holdings Limited |
| 12/02 Review | Edward Terence Miles v The Jet Centre Limited t/a The Private Jet Company |
| 12/56 | Paul Mitchinson v Lloyds TSB Offshore Limited |
| 12/106 | Michael Ferrer v Wessex Garage Limited |
| 12/34 | Mrs Aileen Fraser v The Department of Education and Children |
| 12/94 | Jennifer Alison Foy v Mr Elton Sheldon, Director of Crown Holdings Limited, and Mr Elton Sheldon and Mr Elton Sheldon Managed Airport Developments Limited |
| 12/47 | Hodgson v Victoria Garage '89 Limited (t/a Padgetts Direct) |
| 12/114 | Jonathan Mark Cannell v Manx Telecom Limited |
| 13/04 | Adriana Helen Watson v Barclays Private Clients International Limited |

Updated 8 May 2013